1962-65 (Auditorium still under construction)
1965-66 Bye Bye Birdie
1966-67 The Unsinkable Molly Brown
1967-68 Brigadoon
1968-69 My Fair Lady
1969-70 The Sound of Music
1970-71 Oklahoma
1971-72 Camelot
1972-73 The King and I
1973-74 The Music Man
1974-75 Carousel
1975-76 Kismet
1976-77 The Pajama Game
1977-78 My Fair Lady
1978-79 Brigadoon
1979-80 Kismet
1980-81 The Fantastiks
1981-84 (No musicals performed)
1984-85 Oklahoma
1985-86 The Unsinkable Molly Brown
1986-87 Bye Bye Birdie
1987-88 South Pacific
1988-89 The Music Man
1989-90 Oklahoma
1990-91 Guys and Dolls
1991-92 Fiddler on the Roof
1992-93 My Fair Lady
1993-94 Bye Bye Birdie
1994-95 Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
1995-96 Peter Pan
1996-97 West Side Story
1997-98 The Pirates of Penzance
1998-99 Seven Brides for Seven Brothers
1999-2000 The Wiz
2000-01 Oklahoma
2001-02 Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
2002-03 Footloose
2003-04 Fiddler on the Roof
2004-05 Anything Goes
2005-06 Bye Bye Birdie
2006-07 West Side Story
2007-08 Beauty and the Beast
2008-09 Seussical
2009-10 Curtains
2010-11 Cinderella
2011-12 Aida
2012-13 The Will Rogers Follies
2013-14 The Wiz
2014-15 In the Heights
2015-16 Carousel
2016-17 Mary Poppins
2017-18 Les Miserables
2018-19 Hairspray